March 24, 2025

The Economics of Prioritizing New Customers Over Retaining Existing Ones: Rethinking the "Customer Movement"

Economics of Prioritizing New Customers Over Retaining Existing Ones

Growth is often synonymous with acquiring new customers. Many brands allocate significant portions of their budgets to advertising, influencer marketing, and promotions—all aimed at bringing in fresh faces to their customer base. But is this focus on acquisition at the expense of retention really the most sustainable strategy? The answer lies in understanding the economics of the customer lifecycle and the true value of "Customer Movement."

The Cost of Acquisition vs. Retention

It’s well-documented that acquiring a new customer can cost five to seven times more than retaining an existing one. Acquisition campaigns require ongoing investments in paid media, creative production, and often, hefty discounts to lure first-time buyers. In contrast, retention-focused initiatives, such as loyalty programs, email marketing, and personalized experiences, typically deliver a higher return on investment (ROI) over time.

For instance, consider a brand spending $50 to acquire a customer who makes an initial purchase of $75. After factoring in the cost of goods sold (COGS), shipping, and other expenses, the profit margin shrinks considerably. On the other hand, retaining an existing customer might involve an email marketing cost of just $1, leading to a repeat purchase of $75 with significantly higher profitability.

The Lifetime Value (LTV) Multiplier Effect

Customer lifetime value (LTV) is a key metric for understanding the long-term impact of retention. Loyal customers tend to spend more per transaction, purchase more frequently, and are more likely to advocate for your brand. This multiplier effect means that even a small improvement in retention rates can drive exponential growth in revenue.

A 5% increase in customer retention has been shown to boost profits by 25% to 95%, according to research by Bain & Company. These retained customers also contribute to organic growth through referrals and word-of-mouth, reducing the dependency on costly acquisition channels.

The "Customer Movement" Approach

The concept of "Customer Movement" shifts the focus from one-time transactions to building a community of engaged, loyal customers who move fluidly through different stages of the customer lifecycle. Instead of viewing acquisition and retention as separate silos, "Customer Movement" emphasizes the interconnectedness of these efforts.

This approach requires brands to:

  • Understand the Journey: Shift the focus from one-time transactions to fostering deep customer engagement. Map out the ideal customer journey—from first touchpoint to repeat purchases and advocacy—ensuring every interaction strengthens the relationship.

  • Leverage Actionable Data: Retention starts with good data. Utilize metrics like churn rate, repeat purchase rate, and LTV to uncover growth opportunities. With a  360° customer view, brands gain insights into transactional behaviors, preferences, and qualitative data—all critical for measuring and improving retention.

  • Prioritize Personalization: Customers expect more than generic offers. Hyper-personalized experiences using zero-party data, tailored engagement activities (polls, surveys, games), and data-driven incentives that resonate on an individual level should be a critical part of your strategy

  • Invest in Community: A thriving community isn’t just about engagement—it’s a strategic growth engine. By fostering spaces where customers connect, share, and provide feedback, brands unlock invaluable insights that fuel long-term loyalty and revenue.

All the above ensure that Brands create movements that turn customers into lifelong advocates. 🚀

Balancing Acquisition and Retention

While retention is often more profitable, acquisition is still a critical component of growth. However, the key lies in finding the right balance. Brands that integrate retention strategies into their acquisition efforts—such as onboarding programs, first-purchase incentives tied to loyalty programs, or value-driven messaging—are more likely to build a sustainable business model.

By fostering "Customer Movement," brands can create a seamless experience that encourages new customers to become loyal advocates. For example, instead of offering a one-time discount to new customers, why not invite them to join a loyalty program that rewards them for ongoing engagement? This not only reduces churn but also increases the chances of repeat purchases.

The Hidden Costs of Prioritizing Acquisition

Brands that prioritize acquisition over retention often face hidden costs that erode profitability:

  • Higher Churn Rates: Customers acquired through aggressive discounts or promotions are more likely to churn if they don’t see ongoing value.
  • Brand Dilution: Over-reliance on discounts can undermine brand perception and attract price-sensitive buyers who are less loyal.
  • Opportunity Costs: Every dollar spent on acquisition is a dollar not invested in deepening relationships with existing customers.

Making the Shift: Retention as a Growth Driver

To unlock the full potential of the "Customer Movement," brands need to view retention as a core growth strategy rather than an afterthought. This shift involves:

  • Measuring What Matters: Track metrics like customer retention rate, LTV, and engagement to gauge the effectiveness of your retention strategies.
  • Reallocating Budgets: Shift a portion of your acquisition spend toward retention-focused initiatives.
  • Building Loyalty Programs: Create programs that reward not just purchases but also engagement behaviors like referrals, reviews, and social media interactions.

Conclusion: Fueling Customer Movement for Sustainable Growth

Growth isn’t just about acquiring new customers—it’s about keeping them engaged, connected, and coming back. Brands that focus solely on transactions risk missing the bigger opportunity: creating a Customer Movement that turns buyers into loyal advocates.

Cohora helps brands go beyond traditional retention strategies by leveraging a 360° customer view, actionable data, and personalized engagement to foster deeper connections. With a community-driven approach, brands can create meaningful interactions that drive long-term loyalty and revenue.

With Cohora, you're not just retaining customers—you’re igniting a Customer Movement that fuels sustainable growth.

Are you ready?

Transform your retention marketing and drive growth.
Learn How
LinkedInEmail
Related Blog

You may also read

Cost of a one-time customer
July 8, 2025
What Is a One-Time Customer Really Worth to Your Brand?
Learn the real value of a one-time customer in e-commerce. See how acquisition costs, low return rates, and retention strategies impact customer lifetime value and profitability.
Read More
Learn More
Ulta + VaynerMedia Is a Smart Play
June 25, 2025
Ulta + VaynerMedia Is a Smart Play. Here's How to Maximize the Momentum.
Ulta’s partnership with VaynerMedia is a masterclass in modern brand building. It’s fast, culturally fluent, and creatively fearless. But even the best campaigns are just the beginning. With Cohora, brands like Ulta can take that momentum and build something even more powerful, lasting customer relationships that fuel loyalty, advocacy, and long-term growth.
Read More
Learn More
May 28, 2025
The Loyalty Program You Designed in 2018 Is Failing You
Customers today expect more than discounts in exchange for their data. They want to feel seen, appreciated, and valued beyond the transaction. That means exclusive experiences, personalized perks, and content that actually feels… well, human. They don’t just want points. They want connection. And connection isn’t scalable if your loyalty system is stuck in the past.
Read More
Learn More