October 16, 2025

Stop Turning BFCM Into a One-Night Stand

Cohora Black Friday & Cyber Monday Best Practices

Stop Turning Black Friday & Cyber Monday Shoppers Into One-Night Stands.

Black Friday and Cyber Monday are the biggest retail/ecommerce moments of the year. We see budgets explode, discounts dominate, and ad costs skyrocket. And for a few shorts days, ecommerce looks unstopabble.

What most brands overlook is that more than 70% of BFCM shoppers never come back.

So while your Q4 revenue spikes, your gross customer retention rate drops off a cliff.

Why Black Friday and Cyber Monday "Success" Isn't Always Success

Every November, brands pour millions into acquisition campaigns that look great on paper but fail in practice.

If you're running paid ads, influencer deals, or deep discount promotions, you're likely facing:

  1. Higher CAC (customer acquisition costs)
  2. Lower LTV (lifetime value)
  3. Diminishing margins after shipping, returns, and refunds

What happens next? Those hard-won customers vanish. They unsibscrribe, ignore emails, and never return to your site. With so much competition, they might even forget your brand name completely.

This is why ecommerce retention is now the most overlooked opportunity in marketing.

Aquisition makes noise
Retention drives strategic growth

Imagine if Your BFCM Investment Carried Into 2026

What if your Black Friday shoppers didn't disappear after checkout? What if every new buyer became part of your brand community, feeding your retention and referral loops well into the next year?

That's where Cohora comes in.

Cohora helps ecommerce brands turn one-time buyers into lifelong advocates by transforming post0purchase engagement into a growth engine. Instead of worrying about the next transaction - strategically engaging with your customers between transactions has the potential to shift the relationship and the conversation.

With Cohora. brands can:

  • Collect zero-party data directly from customers through interactive surveys, polls, and experiences
  • Deliver personalized content and offers that keep customers active long after BFCM ends
  • Build community-driven engagement hubs where your customers connect, share, and inspire others
  • Drive repeat purchases, referrals, and loyalty - automatically

You already invest in bringing customer through the door. Cohora makes them stay.

The Smartest BFCM Strategy? Don't Let it End On Monday

Black Friday and Cyber Monday shouldn't be your finish line. They should be your starting point for 2026 growth.

Here's How To Rethink Your BFCM Strategy

  • Post-Purchase Activation: Turn thank-you emails into experiences that collect preferences, interests and feedback.
  • Enhance Customer Segmentation: Use zero-party data to tailor content and offers to each new shopper comlimenting transactional value
  • Engagement Loops: Keep Buyers connected through community content, social integrations, and rewards
  • Retention Measurement: Track how engaged your BFCM buyers stay over time and which actions drive repeat purchases

That's how you turn a 4-day sales window into 12+ months of growth.

Don't Let Your Q4 Investment Expire

If 70% of your BFCM customers are one-and-done, it's not a marketing problem, it's a retention problem.

And Retention is where your next big ROI lives.

Stop pouring millions into short-term acquisition and start compounding your results. Cohora helps your extend your BFCM impact beyond Q4 by turning post-purchase engagement into your most powerful retention game.

This Black Friday, make your investment last longer than the discount. That's what Cohora is for.

Are you ready?

Transform your retention marketing and drive growth.
Learn How
LinkedInEmail
Related Blog

You may also read

Social Identity Gap
September 16, 2025
The Social Identity Gap: Why E-Commerce Marketers Are Flying Blind
Most brands don't know which social followers are real customers. Learn how closing the Social Identity Gap helps e-commerce marketers prove ROI, boost retention, and turn engagement into revenue.
Read More
Learn More
August 7, 2025
3 Ways to Measure Retention, Only One Tells the Whole Story
Customer Return Rate and Repeat Customer Rate only tell part of the story. Learn why Gross Retention Rate is the clearest signal of loyalty, revenue health, and sustainable growth for your e-commerce brand.
Read More
Learn More
Why Now Is the Right Time to Rethink Customer Retention | Cohora
July 31, 2025
Why Now Is the Right Time to Rethink Retention
Discover why investing in customer retention now drives efficient growth, lowers costs, and builds long-term resilience for your e-commerce brand.
Read More
Learn More